Some of Earth’s Extinct Giant Animals May Have Been Smaller Than We Thought

By Jurassic JennSep 27, 2024 12:04 PMScience
Share:
Some of Earth’s Extinct Giant Animals May Have Been Smaller Than We Thought
Perucetus colossus. Source: cdn.sci.news

Researchers now suggest that body size estimates for Earth's extinct giants may have been overly inflated. Methods of estimation have recently faced scrutiny, with the effectiveness of initial calculations called into question.

Reevaluating Dunkleosteus

Take Dunkleosteus, an ancient armored fish known for its formidable bite around 360 million years ago. Previously, it was believed to reach lengths of up to 10 meters, based on the large fossilized remains of its head. However, doubts about the head-to-body ratio employed in those estimates have caused scientists to reconsider. Recent analyses imply that Dunkleosteus might have actually measured only about half that length and had a more robust body, leading some researchers to refer to it as "Chunkleosteus."

A Shift in Perception

Similar reassessments are occurring across various other extinct species, emphasizing caution with size estimates. The studies discussed in the journal Ecology and Evolution highlight a growing trend of exaggeration in reported size. As evolutionary biologist Joel Gayford points out, these discussions often see initial claims of record-breaking sizes or weights quickly challenged by subsequent research, providing a more accurate view.

When assessing body sizes, sometimes the fossil evidence is limited. For instance, the notorious Otodus megalodon, the largest shark known, is only represented by teeth alone. Similarly, the ancient whale Perucetus supplied scant evidence, with only a few vertebrae and one pelvis available for study. Researchers often rely on comparisons to living relatives or employ evolutionary analyses, yet these methods introduce assumptions.

Some of Earth’s Extinct Giant Animals May Have Been Smaller Than We Thought
Four famous ocean dwellers, known from just a few scant fossils, may each have been a bit smaller than first thought. At top are the skull of the ancient armored fish Dunkleosteus terrelli (a), the tooth whorl of the fish Helicoprion (b), a tooth from the giant shark Otodus megalodon (c), and vertebra from the whale Perucetus colossus (d). Past reconstructions of these creatures are in grey, with black silhouettes representing newer, revised reconstructions — though these, too, are still uncertain. (Fossils are not to scale.). Source: J.H. Gayford et al/Ecology and Evolution 2024

The Megalodon Dilemma

Gayford and colleagues scrutinized the Megalodon size estimates, which were previously linked to great white sharks. These assumptions led to a belief in a robust body structure, expected for a creature the size of 11 meters. A recent study has since revised this view, suggesting that Megalodon could be longer but more streamlined — more akin to a bus than a wide van.

The same caution applies to Perucetus, where newer calculations have redefined its weight. Ongoing debates have reduced the initial weight estimate from as much as 340 metric tons to about 100 metric tons. While this departs from the figures of massive, living blue whales, it remains a formidable size.

The Impact of Size Estimates

The credibility of these "spurious size estimates" can significantly influence perceptions about terrestrial and marine giants. As Gayford cautions, these inflated assessments may affect ecological dynamics, impact food resources, and alter predator-prey interactions. Natural alterations in habitats can result in cascading effects on these animals.

Paleontologists laud the research for bringing light to critical challenges in size estimation. Still, Jack Cooper, a vertebrate paleontologist, believes that not every case was analyzed with equal depth. He raises concerns over the report misrepresenting the replicability of his work on Megalodon, pointing out that accuracy in reporting is crucial for ongoing discussions in paleontology.

Reflecting on Research Trends

Gayford clarified that their comments referred to the rarity of relevant fossils and not a critique of Cooper’s findings. He notes the broader issue of research publication trends, where journals may favor dramatic findings over methodically sound conclusions.

He emphasizes that while size can captivate attention, the fascination with these creatures lies in their uniqueness. "The point is for people to understand that it’s not the size or the weight of an animal that makes it interesting," Gayford explains. "Much can still be learned from these significant, awe-inspiring creatures."

Earlier, SSP told about why dogs stare intently at us.

Top Articles
What double rainbow means in spiritual sense

Meaning of double rainbow as a spiritual sign from above

Oct 16, 2024 13:27 PM
Symbolism and meaning of crickets

Symbolism and meaning of the cricket as a spirit animal

Oct 15, 2024 13:01 PM

Meaning of the yellow butterfly. Symbolism and spiritual meaning of the encounter

Oct 15, 2024 15:05 PM

Keep seeing the number of angel 2222? Read its spiritual meaning

Oct 14, 2024 17:01 PM
More News
Three zodiac signs expected to embark on a journey of self-exploration

Three zodiac signs expected to embark on a journey of self-exploration

Jan 30, 2025 20:56 PM
 Pregnant Kylie Kelce Shows Baby Bump on ‘GMA’

Pregnant Kylie Kelce Shows Baby Bump on ‘GMA’

Jan 30, 2025 19:30 PM

Bristol Palin Details Facial Paralysis; Doctors Suspect Bell’s Palsy

Jan 30, 2025 19:02 PM

What Bamboo Means in a Dream: Discover the True Power of Famous Chinese Symbol

Jan 30, 2025 18:07 PM
 Brody Jenner Discusses Excitement for Wedding to Tia Blanco

Brody Jenner Discusses Excitement for Wedding to Tia Blanco

Jan 30, 2025 17:30 PM
 The Spiritual Meaning of Mopping the Floor

The Spiritual Meaning of Mopping the Floor

Jan 30, 2025 16:59 PM
Jennifer Love Hewitt Reflects on Being Sexualized in Her Teen Years: ‘I Didn’t Even Know What Sexy Meant’

Jennifer Love Hewitt Reflects on Being Sexualized in Her Teen Years: ‘I Didn’t Even Know What Sexy Meant’

Jan 30, 2025 16:30 PM
Kristin Cavallari Shares Rare Photo of 10-Year-Old Son Jaxon

Kristin Cavallari Shares Rare Photo of 10-Year-Old Son Jaxon

Jan 30, 2025 16:01 PM
Serenity and Emotional Balance For Three Zodiac Signs: Horoscope for January 30

Serenity and Emotional Balance For Three Zodiac Signs: Horoscope for January 30

Jan 30, 2025 15:56 PM

Kate Middleton's Heartfelt Visit to Hospice Linked to Princess Diana

Jan 30, 2025 15:56 PM

These zodiac signs will find inspiration: horoscope for January 30-31

Jan 30, 2025 15:34 PM
Three zodiac signs to search for emotional release

Three zodiac signs to search for emotional release

Jan 30, 2025 14:53 PM
What does India symbolize in your dream?

What does India symbolize in your dream?

Jan 30, 2025 14:29 PM
Kay McConaughey and Matthew McConaughey

Kay McConaughey Opens Up About Her Marital History

Jan 30, 2025 14:29 PM
These zodiac signs might find emotional balance and stability: horoscope for January 30-31

These zodiac signs might find emotional balance and stability: horoscope for January 30-31

Jan 30, 2025 13:47 PM

Khloé Kardashian Discusses the Moment That Ended Her Marriage to Lamar Odom

Jan 30, 2025 13:26 PM

Optimism and Learning Opportunities for Three Zodiac Signs: Horoscope for January 30

Jan 30, 2025 13:04 PM
Brandi Glanville

Brandi Glanville's Recent Health Update with Dr. Terry Dubrow

Jan 30, 2025 12:43 PM
Renée Zellweger and Ant Anstead

Renée Zellweger Attends Bridget Jones: Mad About the Boy Premiere with Ant Anstead

Jan 30, 2025 12:22 PM
Three zodiac signs are on the verge of life-altering transformations

Three zodiac signs are on the verge of life-altering transformations

Jan 30, 2025 12:05 PM
Olympic Swimmer Ryan Murphy and Bridget Welcome Their First Baby

Olympic Swimmer Ryan Murphy and Bridget Welcome Their First Baby

Jan 30, 2025 11:38 AM
Emilia Pérez’s Karla Sofía Gascón Responds to Oscars Controversy Regarding Fernanda Torres

Emilia Pérez’s Karla Sofía Gascón Responds to Oscars Controversy Regarding Fernanda Torres

Jan 30, 2025 10:56 AM

A Day of Light-Hearted Fun for Three Zodiac Signs: Horoscope for January 30

Jan 30, 2025 10:34 AM

Christina Haack Discusses Ex-Husband Josh Hall's Behavior Before Divorce

Jan 30, 2025 09:51 AM
 Spiritual Meaning of Pigeon Coming Into House

Spiritual Meaning of Pigeon Coming Into House

Jan 30, 2025 09:32 AM
These zodiac signs should focus on money and finances: horoscope for January 30-31

These zodiac signs should focus on money and finances: horoscope for January 30-31

Jan 30, 2025 09:08 AM